And now back to our regularly scheduled programming.
Time for a thought experiment, a light-hearted yet cautionary tale.
One image which keeps poking into my awareness these days is that of a caterpillar entering its cocoon stage and later emerging as a butterfly. I guess there could be some similarities with my current situation.
The humble little caterpillar emerges as a magnificent butterfly.
There is indeed lots of symbolism we can attach to the image of the chrysalis (cocoon), but is any of it truly applicable to the human condition? So if we were to play around with the imagery of transformation and metamorphosis in the insect world, would it be of any help to us in reaching a deeper understanding of ourselves?
Most of us likely derive this picture of a quiet metamorphosis from something we've seen quaintly represented in a picture book (The Hungry Caterpillar wasn’t it?). How cute! After putting in my time as a dull and dreary caterpillar, I get to become a butterfly with wings and everything - sounds like heaven as a reward or enlightenment as a reward right?
But, I think this merits a deeper look because if you drill down and look at the actual process with a state of innocent perception, you can see that the caterpillar is always doing just what a caterpillar does. Eat and poop. Eat and poop. It’s a pretty good life if you manage to stay away from the robins of the world. In one way, the caterpillar's life is complete and whole just as it is. Moment to moment, it is a caterpillar just being a caterpillar. It's not a caterpillar grudgingly going through the motions of being what it is right now knowing that something better is just around the corner. It doesn't desire to be anything else. It can’t be anything else but itself.
And then one day, out of the blue, the caterpillar gets this odd urge to stop eating and of all the damn things it could imagine, and it starts to wrap itself up in silk thread as snugly as possible. After weeks of just eating and pooping, there’s been a change. Slowly, slowly, the caterpillar spins itself inside a cocoon. What do you think this creature is feeling as its habituated life changes? Is it weaving a death shroud? Perhaps it may feel like that, having a life change without knowing what might come after this. And certainly, the creature in its pre-cocoon state of being is neither pleasant nor cute.
And from the caterpillar’s point of view, it can’t possibly be aware that it is at step two of a three-step process. The creature can’t possibly know what lies ahead.
"Dum de dum, if I wrap myself tightly and nearly die, that means I'll get to become something else. Yeah, I think I’ll try that." The caterpillar simply doesn’t know the outcome as it spins the cocoon of deep sleep. If it has an inner voice, it's probably saying things like “Stop this insane behavior right now. Stop it! But I CAN’T stop it. What is wrong with me?” No, the caterpillar does not go to sleep with visions of multi-colored wings dancing through its mind. More likely it thought: "WTF was I thinking? Must have been that hemp leaf I ate yesterday."
Many days later the deep sleep is finished and the butterfly emerges. Does the changeling even remember it was a caterpillar I wonder? Does it regret the change? What an easy life that one was. Eat, poop. Repeat. Now, it’s about - find Mister Right, have sex, lay eggs, and then die. "Oh if I’d only known!" Or when the butterfly sees another caterpillar, does it think, "there but for the grace of God go I?"
This part, for me, raises the most interesting aspects of this whole exercise. Since we have already seemed to move this whole thought experiment to an anthropomorphic level, might a butterfly and caterpillar even be able to communicate? Although sharing the same biology (of sorts), and of course the same caterpillar language, does the metamorphosis create a communicative disconnect due to the drastic experience now included in the butterfly’s caterpillar based butterfly-ness? And how would a caterpillar even imagine that a creature so unlike itself would be the true end of its becoming? How would the butterfly express that change to a caterpillar? How do you describe a dream using only a waking language? Or rather, being awake, how does one speak into a dream?
Assuming that the butterfly has no new words, how would it express that transformative experience to the caterpillar in only 'caterpillar terms'? Since the caterpillar has absolutely no possible imaginational ability to see how that lumpy dumpy old me could become a movie star with wings, then how would the butterfly shout back across that gulf? Would the metamorphic experience make the butterfly seem like a mad being, capable only of unintelligent gibberish?
But if the butterfly could communicate something of the experience, then what would it say? Tell the caterpillar not to be afraid if it stops eating and then gets the urge to starts wrapping itself up?
"Don't worry, it will lead to greater things."
“Uh-huh. Right. Stop eating and go to sleep? I’m not so sure about that plan. Honestly, I kind of like what I’m doing now, thank you very much.”
Hard to find a satisfying answer for the caterpillar. Most explanations would likely cause nightmares rather than stimulating a desire of hoping for the same outcome.
“Hey, I used to be just like you. No, really. Then one day I thought, screw it, I’ll just give all that up, wrap myself up, and take a nice long meditation spa retreat, and see what happens. Spiffy set of wings, eh? Oh, yeah, and I got a bonus; I lost the love handles.”
“How do I know if that will happen for me? How can I trust you? You’re nothing like me. This sausage body becomes that? What if I never wake up?”
“Never wake up? I woke up. Ah, come on. What do you have to lose? The view from up here is AMAZING! Don’t you want to be just like me?”
If caterpillars could talk, then every caterpillar would probably have a butterfly encounter story to tell. From a caterpillar's point of view, butterflies, on the whole, are beautiful to look upon but annoying to converse with. Given that, it's likely that most caterpillars would rather sidestep the destiny of becoming one if at all possible.
But fortunately, the true course of nature is that caterpillars live moment by moment, accepting change as it comes without question, following the flow to becoming what was marked out for them ever since they were laid as an egg. And becoming that, the butterfly then flies off into the fields, leaving the other caterpillars to do their caterpillar thing.


